Call Us Now
Email Us Now
What is a Court-Martial Appeal?
Those convicted by a military court-martial need to understand that their legal fights do not need to end there and then. Military justice allows convicted service members to challenge unjust or erroneous convictions through a complex appellate process. Suppose your conviction involved misinterpretations of the facts, procedural errors, or mistaken facts. In that case, you may have grounds for filing an appeal and battling for a more favorable outcome.
Court-martial appeals are not retrials. The appeals process is the legal means for the original court trial to be reviewed for potential legal or factual mistakes. The court martial appeals process focuses on whether your original military trial properly followed the necessary procedures, questions whether your rights were ever violated, and seeks to determine whether the conviction was lawfully imposed. In many military defense cases, the court-martial appeals process starts soon after the conclusion of the original trial. The appeal must be initiated within a strict time window. The time limits for filing court martial appeals vary depending on the severity of the sentences and the court martial levels. In most court-martial cases, defendants will have 60 days from the sentencing date to begin their appeal process. You may qualify for an automatic review in cases with punitive discharge, a year or more of confinement, and other harsh penalties.
There are three types of court-martial: general, special, and summary. Summary court martials allow those convicted to appeal their convictions to the next level of command, provided they do so within five days of their sentencing. The higher-ranked commander can reduce your sentence, eliminate the punishment, or leave the sentencing as is. It is worth noting that the higher-ranking commander does not have the authority to increase your penalty in a summary court-martial appeal. In summary court martials, you will not have the ability to appeal your conviction to military appeals courts. However, if the higher-ranking commander’s ruling is still unsatisfactory, that decision could be appealed.
Both general and special court martial convictions can be appealed through the military appeals courts. In both instances, these court martial rulings are sent to the convening authorities who originally suggested the military case be seen by a court martial. The referring party can then reduce, eliminate, or leave the sentencing as it is, but cannot increase the punishments during appeals. Convening authorities can consult with Judge Advocates for legal advice in rendering their decisions.
What Are the Four Military Courts of Appeal?
- There are four criminal appeals courts in the United States military. They are the following:
- The Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals
- The Army Court of Criminal Appeals
- The Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals
- The Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals
The armed forces branch that coincides with the convicted individual’s service automatically reviews court martial cases, including sentences of one year or more of confinement, disciplinary discharges, and death penalty cases.
Automatic reviews are limited to specific penalties, but the courts of appeal can also review other cases. Convicted individuals whose court-martial cases do not automatically qualify for reviews can submit special requests to the Judge Advocate General. In most cases, these requests are denied.
For more assistance, please get in touch with our law firm.
What May Be Acceptable Grounds for Appeals?
Those hoping to file an appeal need more than simple disagreement or dissatisfaction with the military court’s verdict. Convicted individuals must show a legal or factual basis that undermines the outcome of their court-martial case.
Legal errors may include misapplication of the law, incorrect rulings on evidence, and improper instructions to juries. Factual errors can consist of discrepancies between what occurred and the trial record.
As your lawyers, we will look for errors that could be grounds for an appeal. For example, perhaps the military judge abused discretion in allowing certain types of evidence, unlawful command influence, abuse of authority, procedural violations, jurisdictional errors, or insufficient facts in the criminal case.
How to Appeal a Court-Martial After a Military Conviction?
Summary court martial cases relate to minor criminal offenses. Defendants in these cases cannot appeal to military appellate courts. Still, they can request reviews by the next level of military command within five days of sentencing.
Special court martials address mid-level offenses, and general court martials are reserved for more serious criminal charges. Provided your punishment meets certain legal thresholds, your case could be automatically sent to the appropriate military criminal appeals court.
Suppose the JAG does not automatically review or forward your case. In that case, your defense attorneys must understand how to file a legal action in the armed forces tribunal by petitioning the Court of Appeals and showing good cause as to why your criminal conviction should be reviewed.
Military appellate courts do not hear new evidence or reconsider factual disputes unless there are undeniable errors obvious in court transcripts. Instead, appellate courts will seek to review and determine sentencing fairness, assess reasonable doubt in a guilty verdict, search for legal or procedural mistakes in the court proceedings, and determine whether your plea was voluntary.
If your appeal is denied by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, you could petition the United States Supreme Court to hear your case. The Supreme Court only reviews a few cases annually. It is afforded broad discretion about which cases it will decide to hear.
Do You Have Other Options Worth Considering?
If your appeal fails, other options may still be available.
In cases involving extraordinary claims of unjust and unlawful confinement, you may be able to file a writ of habeas corpus. This legal option is available to lower-level criminal appeals, military court, or branch-specific Court of Appeals cases. The writ of habeas corpus should be considered a last resort, as such appeals are rarely granted.
Convicted service members also have the right to seek clemency or a pardon. Requests for leniency involve asking military authorities to set aside convictions or reduce the sentences of court-martial convictions. You can request clemency at any time during or after the appellate process.
Contact Our Law Firm to Schedule a Strategy Session with Our Military Defense Lawyers Today
Those seeking to have their military criminal convictions overturned or dismissed would benefit from the legal services of experienced attorneys well-versed in military appellate courts and the applicable laws. Our Kansas law firm has extensive experience representing clients in military defense matters, including those seeking to challenge their military convictions.
To learn more about the benefits of retaining our legal representation, please get in touch with our law office to schedule your initial consultation with our lawyers today.
You can schedule your strategy session with our legal team by contacting us at 913-514-0909.
